Why HMRC Refused the TJ Dowey DIY Housebuilder VAT Claim, and What It Means for Your Build

If you are building your own home, you may be able to recover VAT on certain eligible building materials through the DIY Housebuilders Scheme.

However, the scheme does not allow you to recover every amount of VAT shown on your invoices. In particular, VAT charged incorrectly by a contractor or supplier cannot simply be included in your DIY claim.

That point was considered in the 2026 First-tier Tribunal case of Thomas Joseph Dowey v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 626 (TC). The case provides useful guidance for anyone involved in a self-build project, as well as accountants and construction professionals advising them.

The decision is not a reason to panic. It does, however, show why checking the VAT treatment of invoices during the build is important.

What happened in the TJ Dowey case?

Mr Dowey was building a new home and submitted a claim under the DIY Housebuilders Scheme.

One of the costs included in his claim was a bespoke kitchen and island. The supplier had charged VAT at the standard rate, amounting to approximately £4,900.

The supply should have been zero-rated in the circumstances. Mr Dowey had paid the invoice, including the VAT, and included the VAT in his claim to HMRC.

HMRC accepted the wider claim but refused to refund the VAT charged on the kitchen. Its position was that the VAT had been charged incorrectly and was therefore not eligible for recovery under the DIY scheme.

Mr Dowey then attempted to pursue the amount as overpaid VAT under section 80 of the VAT Act 1994.

The First-tier Tribunal concluded that he could not do this. The appeal was struck out because the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to hear it.

You can read the First-tier Tribunal decision for the full legal reasoning.

VAT consultant checking a contractor invoice beside housebuilding plans

The key VAT point: incorrectly charged VAT is not your input VAT

The DIY Housebuilders Scheme is intended to put a self-builder in a similar position to someone buying a new home from a property developer.

In broad terms, the scheme allows recovery of eligible VAT on qualifying building materials used in the construction of a new dwelling. The rules are specific, and the goods must meet the scheme’s conditions.

The scheme does not provide a general refund for any VAT that happens to appear on a contractor’s invoice.

Where a supplier charges VAT incorrectly, that amount is treated as overpaid output VAT. It is not the customer’s input VAT simply because the customer paid it.

This distinction is important:

  • The customer pays the supplier the amount shown on the invoice.
  • The supplier accounts for the VAT to HMRC through its VAT return.
  • If the VAT was charged incorrectly, the supplier is the person who must correct its VAT position.
  • The customer cannot normally claim that VAT directly from HMRC through the DIY Housebuilders Scheme.

The Tribunal also confirmed that a section 80 claim belongs to the person who accounted for the VAT to HMRC. In this situation, that was the supplier, not Mr Dowey.

This means that the correct route is normally to ask the supplier to correct the invoice and refund the VAT directly.

What should you do if VAT has been charged incorrectly?

If a contractor or supplier has charged VAT when the work should have been zero-rated, raise the issue as soon as possible.

You should ask the supplier to:

  1. Review the VAT treatment of the supply.
  2. Confirm whether the work or materials qualify for zero-rating.
  3. Issue a credit note cancelling the incorrect invoice, where appropriate.
  4. Issue a corrected invoice with the correct VAT treatment.
  5. Refund the VAT that was incorrectly charged.

The supplier can then correct its VAT records and, where appropriate, reclaim the overpaid VAT from HMRC.

You should not simply include the incorrectly charged VAT in your DIY claim and hope that HMRC will resolve the position later. The current HMRC guidance on the DIY scheme specifically confirms that VAT charged in error cannot be claimed from HMRC.

Dealing with the issue early is also practical. If the invoice is reviewed months or years later, the supplier may be difficult to contact, may have stopped trading, or may not have sufficient records to correct the position easily.

What does the decision mean for your self-build?

The case highlights several practical points for anyone building a new home.

Check the VAT position before work starts

Before signing a contract or accepting a quotation, ask the contractor to explain the VAT treatment of the work.

For a qualifying new dwelling, certain construction services may be zero-rated. Building materials supplied and installed by a contractor may also be zero-rated where the relevant conditions are met.

The position can be more complicated where:

  • You buy materials yourself.
  • The contractor supplies both goods and services.
  • The work includes items that may be treated as furniture or appliances.
  • The project includes an extension, conversion or retained structure.
  • The property will have more than one use.
  • The planning permission includes restrictions or conditions.

A VAT consultant can help you review the proposed arrangements before the work begins. This is often more effective than trying to correct a problem after the invoices have been paid.

Review every invoice promptly

Do not leave VAT checks until the end of the build.

Review invoices as they arrive and check:

  • The supplier’s VAT registration details.
  • The description of the goods or work.
  • The VAT rate applied.
  • Whether the invoice relates to an eligible cost.
  • Whether the invoice is addressed correctly.
  • Whether the amount claimed agrees with your records and payment evidence.

If something does not look right, ask the supplier to explain it. A clear written explanation can help you understand whether the issue is a genuine VAT error or simply a cost that falls outside the DIY scheme.

VAT consultant comparing a corrected invoice and credit note

Keep the paperwork

A DIY Housebuilders claim must be supported by evidence.

You should keep copies of:

  • VAT invoices.
  • Bills and credit notes.
  • Proof of payment.
  • Building contracts and quotations.
  • Planning permission.
  • Approved plans.
  • Completion evidence.
  • Correspondence about any corrected invoices.
  • Calculations showing how the claim was prepared.

HMRC may ask for invoices and other documents to check the claim. The invoice should normally show the supplier’s name, address and VAT registration number, the date of issue, a description of the goods and the VAT treatment.

You should also keep a clear record of any invoices that were corrected. If you originally received an invoice showing VAT and later received a credit note and replacement invoice, retain both documents together.

Be aware of the claim deadline

The DIY Housebuilders Scheme generally allows only one claim.

For buildings completed on or after 5 December 2023, the claim must normally be made within six months of completion. Older projects may be subject to the previous three-month deadline.

The exact deadline can depend on the date of completion and the evidence used to establish completion. If you are approaching the deadline, do not delay while trying to resolve every uncertainty. Take advice promptly and make sure the claim is supported by the required documents.

The scheme also has detailed rules about which goods qualify. Items such as building materials incorporated into the building may qualify, while professional fees, tools, plant, most appliances, carpets and many types of furniture do not.

Is there anything to do if your claim has already been refused?

If HMRC has rejected all or part of your claim, read the decision carefully to understand the reason.

You may be able to:

  • Provide additional information or invoices.
  • Ask HMRC for an internal review.
  • Appeal to the independent tax tribunal where there is a valid right of appeal.

However, the best response depends on why the claim was refused.

If the problem is missing evidence, additional documents may resolve the issue. If the problem is that VAT was charged incorrectly, the more appropriate step is usually to contact the supplier and request a corrected invoice and refund.

Trying to challenge HMRC will not normally turn incorrectly charged VAT into eligible VAT under the DIY scheme.

How we can help with a DIY Housebuilders VAT claim

The rules for self-build VAT can be difficult to apply, particularly when a project involves several contractors, unusual building materials or a mixture of property uses.

We can help you review:

  • Whether the project is eligible for the DIY Housebuilders Scheme.
  • The VAT treatment of contractor work and materials.
  • Whether VAT has been charged where zero-rating may apply.
  • The eligibility of individual invoices.
  • The evidence needed for the claim.
  • The calculation and timing of the refund claim.
  • Correspondence with HMRC or contractors.

We can also provide clear written advice for accountants and other professional advisers supporting a client with a self-build project. If you are an accountancy firm without an in-house VAT specialist, we can work behind the scenes or deal directly with your client, depending on your preferred arrangement.

Our DIY Housebuilder VAT claims service is designed to provide practical support without unnecessary jargon. We also advise on wider VAT on land and property issues for businesses, developers and construction professionals.

The TJ Dowey case is a useful reminder to check the VAT treatment before making a claim. If a contractor has charged VAT incorrectly, the answer is usually to correct the invoice with the supplier, rather than trying to recover the amount through HMRC.

If you would like a review of a DIY claim or a contractor’s VAT treatment, get in touch with us. We will be happy to discuss the project and provide clear, practical advice.

VAT consultant discussing a self-build VAT claim with a homeowner

Share:

On Key

Related Posts

VAT Ready Club Enquiry

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Your name*